Christian/Muslim ThreadsNo Proof Quran Copied from Bible, Gnostic or Jewish Sources1) Loki wrote: See why sometimes it is impossible to argue with some Christians. As long as the Quran talks about the same story as in the apocryphas, it is a proof that the Quran borrowed from that source? But the Quran also contains the same story as in the canonical Gospels and Loki said So, why the dichotomy? That is my reason for saying Loki is careless in his reasonings. 2) I find this even more difficult to understand: Loki wrote that he has "given you 100% certainty that all modern scriptual research about the infancy gospel", he could not provide any backings for his claim of 'modern scriptual research' despite his '100% certainty' and now he wants me to provide a research study to prove he is not wrong! It is the onus of the accuser/prosecutor to prove that the defendant is wrong. If you say the Prophet copied from the apocryphas, then Prove it. As a defendant, I provide the counter-arguments to say you are wrong. 3) I would not like to mention Tisdall except that Liberate was not contented with my arguments and resurfaced the Tisdall enigma. If you agree to drop Tisdall, I have no objections. 4) Loki said Ok. 3 parts here: i) It is impossible to provide proof of who and how the Prophet got his story (so drop the teacher-student idea?) ii) Loki thinks he has the 'evidence of plagiarism' which until now I have yet to see iii) Loki wrote 'speculation of possibilities' which is excatly what he has: SPECULATION and not Proof. 5) Actually, the Quran says: That verse is certainly different from what Loki wrote as "a man dictated to him tales of the ancient". The context of the two statements are totally different. 6) So once again... the day is saved thanks to the Powerpuff girls (sorry just like the quote). But I'm serious. I still have not seen any Proof that the Prophet copied from the apocryphas. salam |
🌈Pride🌈 goeth before Destruction
When 🌈Pride🌈 cometh, then cometh Shame