Christian/Muslim ThreadsCatholicism says Bible is false just like muslims sayAbdallah wrote: Kai replies: This is nothing but critical theology, I study this stuff on a daily basis, and the funny thing is, that it relies solemnly on theories, especially on 18-19 century scholars who or either faught religion to propose naturalism or scholars who through new theories hoped for fame in the academic world. what shocks me is that these theories and speculations are being swallowed even in the universities, particular amongst liberal or pluralistic Catholics, even on high level. What otherwise interests me is that Abdallah keeps imposing Catholocism on born again Christians. He seems to forget that Catholosism is deeply into pluralism, which seeks to combine all religions, and to do this, the religious books need to be amended in that direction, basically to gradually loose their value and credability. Dont be chocked, but they do the same thing with the Koran as well. Amazingally Abdallah seems to have overseen the whole purpose in the posted Catholic article; I saw only a turn toward Pluralism by using the conclusions of ancient deists. As to the two accounts in Genesis 1 and 2 which some scholars in the 18-19 century deemed to be contradictory, it surprises me that Abdallah so quickly jumps on the horse; 1) first of all I would like to ask Abdallah which contradiction he finds in the context of these two passages? 2) Secondly, I would like to know if Abdallah acknowledges the historical methods which the conclusion of these Catholics is based upon, because if the does, he needs to apply them upon the entire Bible, which would exclude prophethood, revelation, miracles and divine intervention, and in that case Abdallah cannot be a Muslim. 3) If these critical methods can and should be applied on the Bible, they should be applied on the Koran as well, and the conclusion would be the same. However, I am not sure that Abdallah is willing to get into this kind of debating. Abdallah wrote: Kai replies: Well if you believe the same about the Bible as these Catholics, then Abdallah the fact is that, they are not Christians and neither are you a Muslim. I assume that since you are unfamiliar with the teaching of the Koran that you are unaware of the fact that a Muslim is obliged to believe in the previous REvelations as they were believed upon by the Jews and Chrisitans in Muhammad's time.
Thus if you Abdallah and these Catholics are correct, then my friend you better find yourself a different religion. |
🌈Pride🌈 goeth before Destruction
When 🌈Pride🌈 cometh, then cometh Shame